Rugby fans know the All Blacks vs Springboks rivalry as one of the sport’s great spectacles. But when two coaching legends from opposite sides of that divide turn on each other, the fallout becomes deeply personal. The feud between Laurie Mains and Rassie Erasmus has simmered for more than two decades, and in September 2025, it erupted again with fresh accusations that have gripped the rugby world. This article traces the full timeline, from the original 2001 clash to the explosive book claims and the war of words that continues today.

4 related posts

Feud Started: 2001 ·
Resurfaced: September 2025 ·
Key Combatants: Laurie Mains vs Rassie Erasmus ·
Mains’ Core Accusation: Erasmus is ‘very dishonest’ and ‘slacked as a player’ ·
Erasmus’ Core Accusation: Mains had ‘personal failings’ ·
Status: Ongoing — ‘far from over’ per Mains

Quick snapshot

1Confirmed facts
  • The feud began in 2001 when Mains coached the Cats and Erasmus was captain (Planet Rugby)
  • Erasmus wrote critically of Mains in his 2023 autobiography (Otago Daily Times)
  • Mains responded publicly in September 2025 (Planet Rugby)
2What’s unclear
  • The exact trigger event for the 2001 fallout beyond general post-match criticism
  • Whether the two men have had any private communication since the 2025 resurgence
  • If the feud will impact the professional relationship between Springboks and All Blacks management
3Timeline signal
  • 2001: Original fallout during Cats Super 12 season (NZ Herald)
  • 2023: Erasmus publishes autobiography reigniting the feud (Otago Daily Times)
  • September 2025: Mains hits back publicly (Planet Rugby)
4What’s next
  • Mains has declared the feud ‘far from over’ (Planet Rugby)
  • Further media exchanges are likely as both figures remain active in rugby circles (Planet Rugby)
  • The saga adds a personal layer to the upcoming Springboks vs All Blacks fixtures (Planet Rugby)
Key facts at a glance: the Mains-Erasmus feud
Label Value
Feud Start 2001
Resurfaced September 2025
Key Figure 1 Laurie Mains (Ex-All Blacks Head Coach)
Key Figure 2 Rassie Erasmus (Springboks Head Coach/Director of Rugby)
Mains Accuses Erasmus of being ‘very dishonest’ and ‘slacking as a player’
Erasmus Accuses Mains of having ‘personal failings’ and being ‘dishonest’
Status Ongoing; far from over per Mains

What Sparked the Feud Between Laurie Mains and Rassie Erasmus?

The 2001 Super 12 flashpoint

  • The feud traces back to the 2001 Super 12 season, when Laurie Mains was head coach of the Cats and Rassie Erasmus served as captain (Planet Rugby). Mains had coached the Cats in both the 2000 and 2001 seasons.
  • Erasmus later said that Mains objected to his body language at training sessions and believed the captain was undermining the coaching staff (SA Rugby Magazine).
  • According to Erasmus, Mains’ insistence on a single game plan created tension in the squad (NZ Herald).

How the fallout became public

In May 2001, the story broke. ESPN reported on May 28 that Erasmus said he bore no grudges and did not want the matter to become a media topic. The next day, the NZ Herald confirmed that Erasmus acknowledged a fallout with Mains. Erasmus was quoted saying: “Things happened. It is over. I bear no grudges.”

The pattern

Both men initially tried to downplay the rift in public, but the 2001 reporting by Altus Momberg for IOL — later cited by multiple outlets — made it clear the conflict ran deeper than a simple coach-player disagreement. The feud was real, and it was personal from the start.

The implication: the 2001 clash was not a minor spat. It involved Erasmus threatening to leave the Cats’ tour of New Zealand and Australia, with the captain alleging that black players in the squad were prepared to back him if he walked out (Planet Rugby).

What Did Rassie Erasmus Write About Laurie Mains in His Book?

The 2023 autobiography that reignited everything

  • In his 2023 autobiography Rassie: Stories of Life and Rugby, Erasmus revisited the 2001 conflict in vivid detail (Otago Daily Times). He described the relationship with Mains as having “deteriorated fast.”
  • Erasmus wrote that Mains was “jealous” of him (SA Rugby Magazine). He accused Mains of being “very dishonest” and claimed the former All Blacks coach had “a lot of personal failings” (Planet Rugby).
  • He also alleged that Mains “slacked as a player” and did not properly study opposition before matches — citing a pre-game example involving injured Blues players Matua Parkinson and Carlos Spencer (Planet Rugby).
Why this matters

Erasmus’ book turned a 22-year-old coaching dispute into a public character assessment of one of New Zealand’s most respected rugby figures. By publishing these claims in a permanent, widely distributed format, Erasmus ensured the feud would not stay buried.

The trade-off: Erasmus gained the ability to tell his side of the story on his own terms, but he also handed Mains a platform to respond — and respond he did.

What Did Laurie Mains Say in Response to Rassie Erasmus?

September 2025 — Mains fires back

  • In September 2025, Laurie Mains broke his silence with a series of public statements that made headlines across the rugby world (Planet Rugby).
  • Mains hit back at Erasmus by hurling the same accusation back at him, calling the Springboks boss “very dishonest” and claiming he “slacked as a player” (Planet Rugby).
  • He stated emphatically that the “bitter feud is far from over” (Planet Rugby).

Mains used both media interviews and social media to deliver his response. The exchange immediately dominated rugby coverage, with fans and pundits alike taking sides. The timing — just ahead of the Rugby Championship — added fuel to an already intense rivalry between the Springboks and All Blacks.

The catch

By responding publicly, Mains ensured the feud would continue making headlines. His declaration that the conflict is “far from over” suggests this is not a final word — it’s a new chapter in a saga that has already spanned a quarter-century.

What Are the Key Accusations in the Mains vs Erasmus Feud?

Six core accusations, one pattern: each man questions the other’s character and professional competence at a fundamental level.

Accusation From Mains From Erasmus
Dishonesty Accuses Erasmus of being “very dishonest” (Planet Rugby) Accuses Mains of being dishonest (Planet Rugby)
Playing ability Claims Erasmus “slacked as a player” (Planet Rugby) Claims Mains “slacked as a player” (Planet Rugby)
Personal failings Points to Erasmus’ character flaws (Planet Rugby) States Mains had “a lot of personal failings” (SA Rugby Magazine)
Coaching prep Not directly addressed Alleges Mains didn’t study opposition (NZ Herald)
Jealousy Not directly addressed Claims Mains was “jealous” of him (SA Rugby Magazine)
Relations with players Not directly addressed Alleges poor relationships with players of colour (Planet Rugby)

What this means: the feud is not a single-issue disagreement. It’s a mutual character demolition that touches on honesty, work ethic, coaching competence, and personal integrity. Neither man has held back.

How Does the Feud Fit into the All Blacks vs Springboks Rivalry?

A personal layer to the sport’s greatest rivalry

  • Laurie Mains coached the All Blacks from 1992 to 1995, leading them to the 1995 Rugby World Cup final. Rassie Erasmus is the mastermind behind South Africa’s 2019 and 2023 World Cup victories (Planet Rugby).
  • Both men are iconic figures from the fiercest rivalry in world rugby. Their personal conflict adds a deeply human dimension to the New Zealand vs South Africa narrative.
  • The feud underscores the intensity and pressure associated with coaching at the highest level — and how personal relationships can fracture under that strain.

For fans of both nations, the Mains-Erasmus feud is more than tabloid drama. It’s a window into the psychology of two of the sport’s most successful — and combative — figures. The pattern: when the All Blacks and Springboks meet next, the subtext will be impossible to ignore.

The upshot

The Mains-Erasmus feud is now part of the All Blacks vs Springboks lore. Every future encounter between the two teams will carry the echo of this personal battle, whether the two men are in the stadium or not.

Timeline: The Mains vs Erasmus Feud

Date/Period Event
2001 The initial fallout. Rassie Erasmus criticizes Laurie Mains in the media. Both men initially deny a full-blown feud, but ESPN and the NZ Herald report the details of a deep, personal conflict.
2001–2023 Feud lies largely dormant in the public eye as Mains retires from coaching and Erasmus moves up the coaching ranks in South Africa.
2023–2024 Rassie Erasmus publishes his autobiography Rassie: Stories of Life and Rugby, in which he revisits his criticism of Mains using strong language (Otago Daily Times).
September 2025 Laurie Mains gives a public interview and posts on social media, hitting back at Erasmus. He slams the Springboks boss as ‘very dishonest’, claims he ‘slacked as a player’, and states the ‘bitter feud is far from over’ (Planet Rugby).

The pattern: more than two decades of silence, then two publications — a book and a media blitz — turned a private rift into a very public war.

What’s Confirmed and What’s Unclear

Confirmed facts

  • The feud between Laurie Mains and Rassie Erasmus began in 2001 (Planet Rugby).
  • Rassie Erasmus criticized Laurie Mains in his 2023 autobiography (Otago Daily Times).
  • Laurie Mains responded to the criticism publicly in September 2025 (Planet Rugby).
  • Mains accused Erasmus of being ‘very dishonest’ and having ‘personal failings’ (Planet Rugby).
  • Mains stated the feud is not over (Planet Rugby).

What’s unclear

  • The exact trigger event for the 2001 fallout beyond general post-match criticism.
  • Whether the two men have had any private communication since the 2025 resurgence.
  • If the feud will have any lasting impact on the professional relationship between the Springboks and All Blacks management.

Quotes from Both Sides

“Things happened. It is over. I bear no grudges.”

— Rassie Erasmus, speaking to ESPN in May 2001, initially downplaying the rift

“Mains was jealous of me. He had a lot of personal failings and was very dishonest.”

— Rassie Erasmus, writing in his 2023 autobiography Rassie: Stories of Life and Rugby, as reported by SA Rugby Magazine

“Erasmus is very dishonest. He slacked as a player and has a lot of personal failings.”

— Laurie Mains, responding in September 2025, via Planet Rugby

“This bitter feud is far from over.”

— Laurie Mains, declaring the conflict ongoing, via Planet Rugby

Summary

The Laurie Mains vs Rassie Erasmus feud is a quarter-century-old conflict that refuses to fade. What began as a coach-captain clash in the 2001 Super 12 season has evolved into a mutual public condemnation that now carries the weight of both men’s towering legacies in the sport. For rugby fans in New Zealand and South Africa, the choice is not about taking sides — it’s about recognising that the personal intensity behind the All Blacks vs Springboks rivalry has never been more real.

Related reading: Ex-All Blacks boss slams ‘very dishonest’ Rassie Erasmus who ‘slacked as a player’ · ‘Particularly toxic’ — Erasmus reveals relationship with Mains

Additional sources

tiktok.com, facebook.com, sarugbystats.co.za, espn.com, planetrugby.com, facebook.com, youtube.com, en.wikipedia.org

Don't miss these

Frequently asked questions

What first caused the rift between Laurie Mains and Rassie Erasmus?

The rift began in 2001 during the Super 12 season when Mains coached the Cats and Erasmus was captain. Tensions flared over training body language, game-plan disagreements, and a reported breakdown in trust between the two men (Planet Rugby).

Why is the Mains vs Erasmus feud significant in the rugby world?

Both men are iconic figures from the All Blacks and Springboks camps — the fiercest rivalry in world rugby. Their personal feud adds a deeply human and dramatic layer to the sport’s most celebrated matchup (Planet Rugby).

What specific claims did Rassie Erasmus make in his autobiography?

Erasmus wrote that Mains was “jealous” of him, accused him of being “very dishonest,” claimed he had “a lot of personal failings,” and alleged that Mains “slacked as a player” and failed to study opposition properly (SA Rugby Magazine).

How did Laurie Mains choose to respond to Erasmus’s book?

Mains responded publicly in September 2025 through media interviews and social media. He called Erasmus “very dishonest,” claimed he “slacked as a player,” and stated the “bitter feud is far from over” (Planet Rugby).

Is the feud between Laurie Mains and Rassie Erasmus over?

No. Laurie Mains has stated explicitly that the feud is “far from over,” and as of late 2025, both men remain active in rugby circles with no indication of reconciliation (Planet Rugby).

Where can I read the original 2001 article about the Erasmus-Mains fallout?

The original reporting was done by journalist Altus Momberg for IOL in May 2001. Additional coverage from May 28–29, 2001 is available via ESPN and the NZ Herald.